• brenucsb twitter avatar
    Covering Crops: How federal crop insurances\ program reforms can reduce costs, empower farmers, an protect natural… https://t.co/DcUnk6dvvE
    3 hours 54 min ago
  • ucsantabarbara twitter avatar
    This #GauchoAlum assists families in finding the right match in staffing for their domestic needs with her company… https://t.co/nxDyExIUlR
    6 hours 49 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Late 12-0 Run Propels UCSB Past UC Irvine, 70-58 https://t.co/m2qU0XrYQS
    16 hours 18 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Behind a career-high 24 kills from Corey Chavers, UCSB men's volleyball topped No. 10 Pepperdine 3-1 Saturday night… https://t.co/D5nsniMX9v
    19 hours 34 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Gauchos Defeat USC for First Time Since 1994 With 6-1 Win https://t.co/Qx2MIg8mlk
    19 hours 51 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    UCSB Swim Earn Double Win Against Pacific https://t.co/5HIEA1jVrZ
    20 hours 35 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    https://t.co/TZEXKzXVyd https://t.co/RBJFqndgNu
    20 hours 46 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Gauchos Topple Cal Baptist; Fall to Michigan on Second Day of Winter Invitational https://t.co/q5hTJ946Cy
    20 hours 48 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Gauchos Top Long Beach on the Road for First Time since 2010-11 https://t.co/LmjZSo4XSU
    20 hours 52 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    https://t.co/SxjQYEoij3 https://t.co/9FACb1DuV5
    20 hours 52 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    @UCSBbasketball tonight at 9pm st the Thunderdome vs. UC Irvine. ESPN and free t-shirts. Students get in free!
    22 hours 42 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Tune in here: https://t.co/9h2e8ItJlN to see @UCSBWWP take on Michigan at Campus Pool at 5pm! #UCSB #gogauchos
    23 hours 52 min ago
  • brenucsb twitter avatar
    About 1/3 of all food made for people is wasted. This study shows how using #aquaculture by-products that are typic… https://t.co/YuoXomoFqA
    1 day 1 hour ago

Giving Credit Where Credit is Due

Informatics expert James Frew and international colleagues suggest a method for bringing academic citation into the database age
Friday, October 14, 2016 - 12:30
Santa Barbara, CA

James Frew 2016.JPG

James Frew

Environmental informatics specialist James Frew

Photo Credit: 

James Badham

Solving today’s environmental problems involves vast amounts of data, which have to be gathered, stored, retrieved, analyzed and — increasingly — cited in academic journals. That last step, however, presents a problem.

“For purposes of honesty and reproducibility, academic publishers are very rapidly moving toward requiring those who publish an article to also publish the data backing it up,” said James Frew, an associate professor in UC Santa Barbara’s Bren School of Environmental Science & Management, and an expert on data storage and provenance. “It’s happening now and is going to affect everybody.”

In a new paper, Frew and colleagues from the University of Edinburgh and the University of Pennsylvania offer a solution whereby citations would be generated automatically. The team’s findings appear in Communications of the ACM, the leading publication of the Association for Computing Machinery.

Citations have the important role of directing readers to supporting information and giving credit where credit is due. While different fields and journals have their own specific citation rules, most are variations on a simple, universally accepted standard. That system has worked well for decades, as long as cited materials were fixed, unchanging objects like books or articles, but it doesn’t transfer to data.

Increasingly, scientific data is stored in large databases with incredibly complex structures and are accessible via the web. While some databases, like those containing election results, are static, others, which may contain yearly demographic data or climatological data from satellites, grow and change over time.

An example is UCSB’s National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis, where working groups create huge data sets by combining smaller sets from multiple researchers. When that data is cited, both the database and the person who originally gathered the data should be included in the citation. However, currently, even if scholars want to cite the sources of data they use, they may not be able to, because no standard tool exists for generating database citations.

“We get one of two extremes in database citation,” Frew said. “Either we get a citation to the complete database package or to a piece of information where the citation is so granular it cannot be connected back to the original data set.” Sometimes a citation is lacking altogether.

Frew and his colleagues describe a system within the database that would automatically generate a citation in a standardized format whenever data is extracted from a database. They suggest that by using the same computing power that makes databases possible, database citations can be made more specific while also accurately accounting for all data authors.

According to Frew, this responsibility will fall to database managers, who would need to take three steps: Define the various ways their data can be queried or “viewed,” create citation templates for the standard set of views and provide a computational mechanism to allow researchers to generate citations for specific queries.

Frew and his team outline a solution and demonstrate its versatility by applying it to two different scientific databases that he described as being “radically different in both their structure and how they should be cited.” Their suggestions lay a foundation for expanding the kinds of citations available to the academic world and offer improvements to database citation by combining computational power with the foresight of database managers.

“My hope is that our suggestions for automating citations will encourage managers to implement similar systems and make it easier for those using the data to cite it appropriately,” Frew said.

Contact Info: 

Julie Cohen
(805) 893-7220