• UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Gilbertson Earns Big West Player of the Week Honor https://t.co/P0wmPtDjNT
    1 hour 37 min ago
  • ucsantabarbara twitter avatar
    When secrets are exposed, can life ever be the same? That question is at the heart of @ucsbTD's “Lydia." https://t.co/r1KKTmmB5N
    7 hours 14 min ago
  • ArtsandLectures twitter avatar
    RT @KCRWinSB: Extreme sports, mountain culture & exotic locations are a few highlights of the @BanffMtnFest. Don't miss it! https://t.co/sR…
    7 hours 16 min ago
  • ArtsandLectures twitter avatar
    .@DrSidMukherjee on the powerful documentary Cancer: The Emperor of All Maladies with @kenburns & @katiecouric https://t.co/p7pRHUrhGr
    7 hours 25 min ago
  • ArtsandLectures twitter avatar
    Fearless foodies, we're prepping for @AltonBrownLive with a giveaway! Find out how you can win #AltonBrown swag!… https://t.co/7xWh29cuct
    7 hours 41 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    WWP: Gauchos Begin Barbara Kalbus Invitational Against No. 8 Michigan https://t.co/p3U6s9Pswr
    7 hours 54 min ago
  • UCSB_GradPost twitter avatar
    Maria Vazquez on seeing the big picture and grad school life lessons https://t.co/8ghZtxLgvN #UCSB #ucsbgradpost
    9 hours 15 sec ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Gauchos Host Riverside in Final Home Game Thursday https://t.co/FPzQSdg2Ae
    9 hours 21 min ago
  • UCSBengineering twitter avatar
    Cryptographer Stefano Tessaro receives early career recognition from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation https://t.co/iQi8qUA6uS
    9 hours 44 min ago
  • AS_UCSB twitter avatar
    Eager to make your mark on campus? Pop into our winter recruitment fair to learn how to get involved with your A.S.… https://t.co/Cp0VIE7bEq
    10 hours 5 min ago
  • brenucsb twitter avatar
    RT @CoraKammeyer: So cool to hear @GlobalEcoGuy speak at @brenucsb about the work @calacademy is doing to explore+explain+sustain our awe-i…
    11 hours 34 min ago
  • ArtsandLectures twitter avatar
    @mrjoshz @benshapiro oops, not an A&L event. Daily Nexus says it was put on by UCSB College Republicans: https://t.co/z8KDFjpXTv
    12 hours 13 min ago
  • brenucsb twitter avatar
    .@GlobalEcoGuy: Museums are the most trusted institutions in the nation w/ high approval ratings from Dems & Republicans alike #BrenTalks
    13 hours 10 min ago
  • ArtsandLectures twitter avatar
    Looking forward to another collaboration #theemperorofallmaladies #thegene https://t.co/BEzznCTSdN
    13 hours 12 min ago
  • brenucsb twitter avatar
    @GlobalEcoGuy: Museums serve ~ 1 billion visitors a year, more than all the sports stadiums & theme parks in the nation combined #BrenTalks
    13 hours 13 min ago

Shame on Us

A new paper by UCSB’s Thomas Scheff provides a first step in arriving at accepted definitions of basic emotions
Monday, December 15, 2014 - 09:30
Santa Barbara, CA

Man crying iStock.jpg

Man crying

Crying is usually not socially acceptable for men and neither are the emotions that provoke it.

Photo Credit: 

iStock

Thomas Scheff.jpg

Thomas Scheff

Thomas Scheff

Photo Credit: 

Courtesy photo

Emotions are complicated and never more so than in the realm of the scientific, where commonly accepted definitions are lacking.

In a paper published in the journal Qualitative Inquiry, UC Santa Barbara’s Thomas Scheff examines the basic emotions of grief, fear/anxiety, anger, shame and pride as they appear in scientific literature in an attempt to take a first step in defining them. “Emotion terms, especially in English, are wildly ambiguous,” Scheff writes in the paper’s introduction.

An emeritus professor of sociology at UCSB, Scheff set out to explore why the language of emotion is so vague. “This paper is a first step toward correcting the chaotic nature of the language of emotion,” Scheff said. “Our society treats emotions as a negligible and largely destructive matter, but that’s a total fib. Emotions are like breathing; they only make trouble when they’re obstructed.”

Using grief as an example, he pointed out that in scientific literature other words, such as “distress” and “sadness,” are used to describe grief. The absence of decisive definitions, he noted, are an impediment to creating common meaning.

In order to delineate first steps toward clarity, Scheff discussed what he calls “four forward-looking studies of shame, the least understood emotion.” In this part of his research, Scheff presented a historical picture of how shame has been defined — and used or ignored — over time.

He began with Norbert Elias, an early-20th-century German sociologist famous for his theory of civilizing processes. Elias suggested a way of understanding the social transmission of the taboo on shame. Decades later, English psychologist Michael Billig proposed that repression begins in social practices of avoidance and went on to explore the nature of repression in detail.

American research psychologist and psychoanalyst Helen Lewis, Scheff’s mentor, used a systematic method to locate verbal emotion indicators in transcriptions of psychotherapy sessions. According to Scheff, Lewis’ findings showed that shame/embarrassment was by far the most frequent emotion, occurring more than all the other emotions combined. However, these citations were virtually never mentioned by either the client or the therapist. Lewis called this  “unacknowledged shame,” which she explained could be hidden in two different ways.

Overt, undifferentiated shame involves painful feelings hidden behind terms that avoid the word “shame.” This type of shame is marked by pain, confusion and bodily reactions such as blushing, sweating and/or rapid heartbeat. Bypassed shame involves fleeting feelings and is followed by obsessive and rapid thought or speech.

“People are so terribly terrified of shame,” Scheff said. “But if you hurt my feelings by saying that my nose is too big and if I pretend that I’m not hurt, then it’s going to hurt me for a long time. I’ll feel ashamed. But if I say, ‘You hurt my feelings,’ then you say, ‘What do you mean?’ and I tell you my feelings, it’s going to be a fairly minor event. Yet we live in a society that bypasses or misnames emotions, especially shame.”

As far back as the 19th century, psychologists have attempted to establish unambiguous emotional constructs by associating physical sensation with emotion. Building on these concepts, Scheff’s latest research included a chart of emotional models supporting the idea that emotions are bodily preparations for actions that have been delayed.

“Shame is a signal that you feel rejected and not accepted just as you are,” he explained. “Pride is a signal that you feel accepted just as you are. But because emotions are hidden in modern societies, we are like actors on a stage, acting instead of doing what we think we should do.”

Using Ngrams — a word search database created by Google Books and based on more than 5.2 million books published between 1500 and 2008 — Scheff verified a historic decline in the use of shame terms in different languages: American English, British English, French, Spanish and German. He found that decreased usage of what he calls the “s-word” is remarkably similar in three of the five languages: American English, British English and French.

Despite the fact that the use of shame terms appears to be declining, Scheff noted that the topic of shame is present in public discourse now more than ever before. “I’ve written a lot about shame and I’ve noticed that it’s more in vogue,” he said. “And the articles and chapters I’ve written about shame have become more popular in the last year or two as well.” Perhaps with more public discussions about shame, that term as well as other emotions will begin to be more precisely defined.

Contact Info: 

Julie Cohen
julie.cohen@ucsb.edu
(805) 893-7220

Topics: