• UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Another G for DePuy gives @UCSBMensSoccer HC Tim Vom Steeg 100th career Big West W. RECAP >> http://t.co/sx2KK2U7UI http://t.co/HMT68OJZ0o
    3 hours 50 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    2 late goals give UCSB a 2-0 win over UCR. Congrats to Tim Vom Steeg, now the first coach to ever reach 100 Big West wins @UCSBMensSoccer
    4 hours 34 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    After beating 3 defenders, @acheampong_iv puts his rocket left foot to work and gives UCSB a 2-0 lead over UCR
    4 hours 46 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    DePuy scores from the left side in the 70th minute to put UCSB up 1-0 over UCR!
    4 hours 57 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Gauchos almost find the breakthrough with the ball dropping nicely to @AhInGa03 but he can't get his shot past the keeper on target
    5 hours 12 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    DePuy and @acheampong_iv with a nice 1-2 and DePuy's shot from the edge of the box forces UCR's keeper to make a nice save. UCSB 0, UCR 0
    5 hours 20 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Kosti Moni gets off a pretty effort with a defender on his side, but the shot goes just past the post. Tied 0-0 with under 2 min left in 1st
    5 hours 43 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    UCSB outshooting Riverside 8-5 with 11 min to go in the first half, but still tied 0-0 @UCSBMensSoccer
    5 hours 53 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    Gauchos get the ball deep into the box Nick DePuy's close range effort sails high. @UCSBMensSoccer still looking to open the scoring
    6 hours 6 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    15 min in @UCSBMensSoccer in full control against UCR. Head Coach Tim Vom Steeg needs just 1 win to be first ever to reach 100 Big West wins
    6 hours 12 min ago
  • UCSBgauchos twitter avatar
    MWP: No. 6 Gauchos Taking on Top Contenders in So Cal Tournament http://t.co/ez8L2CbCkS
    6 hours 57 min ago
  • UCSBLibrary twitter avatar
    #TBT Angela Davis speaks at UCSB, Nov. 4, 1969 http://t.co/wrdfpDBn3d
    9 hours 14 min ago
  • UCSB_GradPost twitter avatar
    UCSB Instructional Development Seeks TA Development Program Coordinator #UCSB
    9 hours 15 min ago
  • UCSB_GradPost twitter avatar
    Versatile Ph.D. Online Panel Discussion Oct 19-23: 'Careers in Publishing' #UCSB
    10 hours 50 min ago
  • UCSB_GradPost twitter avatar
    NSF East Asia and Pacific Summer Institutes Fellowship Program #UCSB
    10 hours 50 min ago

Why Species Matter

A graduate student assesses the underlying assumptions and predictive ability of functional-group models used to study seabed communities
Tuesday, June 17, 2014 - 09:45
Santa Barbara, CA

UC Santa Barbara doctoral candidate Caitlin Fong travels to French Polynesia often but not for vacation. She goes there to study a coral reef ecosystem influenced by human impacts such as overfishing and nutrient pollution.

Her work focuses not only on biological changes but also methods scientists use to determine within-group group responses to ecological processes. The findings are published in ESA Ecology, a journal of the Ecological Society of America.

Fong and Peggy Fong, a professor in UCLA’s Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, conducted a study assessing the usefulness of functional form groups often used by community ecologists. The researchers examined the practice of grouping species with homogenous responses to major ecological forces as well as predicting group responses in established conceptual models.  

They found that the two commonly used models for grouping coral reef macroalgae — the relative dominance model and the functional group model — failed to consistently generate groups that responded uniformly to experimental manipulations of key ecological processes.

“A lot of times, functional group forms are defined based on morphology and phylogeny,” said Caitlin Fong, “but they are defined without empirical testing.” Morphology comprises the specific structural features of organisms while phylogeny deals with their evolutionary relationships.

As an undergraduate, Caitlin Fong visited Moorea in 2010, just months after tropical cyclone Oli hit western French Polynesia. The storm was the final blow to the coral reef, already made vulnerable by an invasion of crown-of-thorns starfish, a coral predator.

“The reef had been subjected to a variety of stressors that caused the loss of coral dominance,” she explained. “In fact, researchers think that increased fishing and changes in land use have resulted in reefs worldwide shifting from coral to macroalgae-dominant states.”

The scientists conducted an experiment that controlled herbivore abundance and nutrient supply to see how those two forces interacted to shape macroalgae communities. They found that functional form groups were not able to capture the dynamics of what was happening on these reefs, particularly as they transitioned from coral to macroalgae dominance.

“It’s not only important that things are shifting,” Caitlin Fong said, “but when macroalgae is abundant, it seems logical to consider the species traits of the dominant spaceholders.” She worked with the area’s four most dominant species: Dictyota bartayresiana, Padina boryana, Galaxaura fasciculata and Halimeda opuntia.

“I’ve actually been back to Moorea every two years and the shift to these fleshy species of macroalgae has been even more extreme,” she noted. “In 2010, Padina was a lot more contained in space but now it has carved a large part of the back reef area where we work.”

The results showed that inappropriate functional form groupings altered the ability to detect important controlling factors. Scale also seemed to affect the detection of ecological processes. “This may be because different ecological processes act at different scales,” Caitlin Fong said. “The resultant loss of information, in turn, masked strong interactions between herbivory and nutrients that were not included in the models.”

The research attributes the limitations of existing models of functional form dominance to the rapid and catastrophic changes in ecosystems caused by humans, which have been documented worldwide. “We postulate that functional-group models may need to be reformulated to account for shifting baselines,” she concluded. “If you don’t want to lose ecological resolution, you need to ensure that the defined groups that you use are true groups as opposed to arbitrary groups without underlying assumptions.”

Contact Info: 

Julie Cohen
(805) 893-7220


After reading this article I feel